The 8 Best French Toasts in NYC October 2025

Saturday mornings in NYC often come with a craving for French toast. With so many brunch spots across the five boroughs, finding a standout dish can feel overwhelming. You don’t want to waste time on soggy bread or overhyped places. That’s why we’ve compiled a list of the eight best French toasts in the city, selected based on insights from trusted food authorities.

Great French toast goes beyond basic ingredients. It’s about using the right bread, perfecting the custard soak, and balancing a crispy exterior with a soft interior. At 8it, we value these details, curating recommendations from NYC’s top critics, chefs, and food pros. From classic challah to creative churro-inspired versions, these dishes impress even the most seasoned palates.

Looking for brunch ideas? Check out our handpicked selections below.

1. Churro French Toast at Winona’s – A Creative Twist

8it review: “Yeah not gone lie this is some peak”

Winona’s churro French toast turns a familiar Spanish treat into an unforgettable breakfast. The dish nails the churro’s signature crispy outside and soft inside, while adding a cinnamon-sugar coating for extra depth. Each bite reveals a mix of textures and flavors, blending comfort with innovation. This is a prime example of how NYC reimagines traditional dishes in fresh, exciting ways.

Try 8it for free to uncover more unique breakfast finds like this.

2. Seasonal French Toast at Third Falcon – Fresh and Authentic

8it review: “A concise seasonal menu influenced by Northern France.”

Third Falcon brings Northern French techniques to their seasonal French toast, adapting flavors based on what’s fresh throughout the year. This approach keeps the dish rooted in tradition while staying relevant to NYC’s changing produce. Expect rich dairy and quality bread in every serving, reflecting a deep respect for classic preparation methods paired with modern tweaks.

See more critic insights on this dish with 8it, where you can explore Third Falcon’s latest seasonal offerings.

3. Challah French Toast at Boutros – Rich and Elevated

8it review: “Super fluffy challah with pistachio-ricotta toppings. RUN HERE.”

Boutros takes challah French toast to new heights with its eggy, slightly sweet bread that soaks up custard perfectly. The pistachio-ricotta topping adds a Mediterranean flair, balancing creamy and nutty notes against the rich base. This isn’t just breakfast, it’s a thoughtfully crafted dish that stands out among typical brunch options.

Try 8it for free to locate more standout challah dishes in NYC.

4. Classic French Toast at Sarabeth’s – Perfectly Executed

8it review: “Satisfying, shiny-custard, egg-soaked, squishy slices griddled golden brown.”

Sarabeth’s proves that mastering the basics can create something remarkable. Their French toast features a well-soaked custard that keeps the bread tender, paired with a golden-brown finish from precise cooking. It’s a straightforward dish done with exceptional care, showing why fundamental techniques matter as much as innovation.

Try 8it for free to find more classic breakfasts worth your time.

5. French Toast Sticks at Sundays Well – Fun and Shareable

8it review: “Crispy outside, served with caramel and whipped cream.”

Sundays Well offers French toast sticks that combine nostalgia with refined flavors. The crispy exterior contrasts a soft center, while caramel and whipped cream add a dessert-like touch. This format invites sharing, making it ideal for lingering brunches that are a staple of NYC weekends.

Chefs and owners share exclusive updates on 8it, including pop-ups and specials before they hit social media. Perfect for food enthusiasts tracking fresh takes on French toast.

6. Stuffed French Toast at Shopsin’s – Bold and Customizable

8it review: “Dozens of ‘slutty stuffed’ options, with omelettelike crust.”

Shopsin’s brings a daring edge to French toast with countless stuffing choices and a unique, fluffy crust reminiscent of an omelet. This generous, indulgent style matches the restaurant’s bold personality, offering a hearty meal that prioritizes variety and excess over restraint.

Try 8it for free to explore Shopsin’s creative menu options.

7. Reliable French Toast at Sarabeth’s Central Park South

8it review: “Satisfying, shiny-custard, egg-soaked, squishy slices griddled golden brown.”

Sarabeth’s Central Park South upholds the same high standards as other locations, delivering consistent quality with every plate. Their systematic approach to custard and griddle timing ensures reliability, whether you’re a local or a visitor near Central Park seeking a true NYC brunch experience.

Try 8it for free to find the Sarabeth’s location that fits your plans.

8. Layered French Toast at Clinton St. Baking Company

8it review: “Layered with caramelized banana, pecans and cinnamon sugar.”

Clinton St. Baking Company crafts French toast with caramelized bananas for sweetness, pecans for crunch, and cinnamon sugar for warmth. Every element works together, creating a balanced, satisfying dish. It’s a thoughtful take that turns a simple meal into a full sensory experience worth the wait.

Discover more about this favorite on 8it, including tips to dodge the long lines at Clinton St. Baking Company.

Finding Great French Toast in NYC: Why 8it Stands Out

Tracking down excellent French toast in NYC doesn’t have to feel like a chore. The tool you use can make all the difference between an average meal and a memorable one. Here’s how 8it compares to standard search options.

Traditional search tools offer plenty of data but often bury you in options of inconsistent quality. Searching for top French toast might yield everything from hidden gems to tourist traps, with no clear way to filter the best. User feedback varies widely, focusing on unrelated factors like ambiance instead of the dish itself.

8it cuts through this clutter by spotlighting only dishes endorsed by food industry experts. Critics using the app trust that every French toast listed meets a high standard, saving time and guesswork. This focus also includes seasonal items and pop-ups that broader platforms overlook, keeping you connected to NYC’s fast-paced food scene.

Try 8it for free to switch from endless searching to instant, reliable food recommendations.

Common Questions About Finding Great French Toast in NYC

What Makes Finding Exceptional French Toast in NYC Hard?

NYC has countless brunch spots, but many serve standard, forgettable French toast. The real challenge lies in spotting places that prioritize bread choice, custard balance, and cooking precision. On top of that, some focus more on flashy presentation than taste, while typical search tools lump all options together without highlighting true standouts.

How Does 8it Guarantee Top French Toast Picks?

8it relies solely on input from established food pros, including media like Eater and respected chefs. Unlike open review platforms, only dishes praised by those with culinary expertise make the cut. If a French toast isn’t up to par, it doesn’t appear on 8it, ensuring every listing reflects quality.

Can I Find Unusual French Toast Styles on 8it?

Yes, 8it often features creative takes on French toast, sourced from industry insiders who seek out innovation. Think churro-inspired versions at Winona’s or stuffed options at Shopsin’s. These aren’t just for show, they’re carefully designed dishes that blend originality with the core appeal of French toast.

How Can 8it Help Plan My Next Brunch?

With 8it’s map feature, finding nearby French toast spots becomes simple. Filter by what’s open now, save favorites to custom lists, or share plans with friends. For limited-time offerings, calendar alerts keep you on track. Direct links to reservations or delivery make going from discovery to dining effortless.

How Is 8it Different from Social Media Food Accounts?

Social media often prioritizes viral content over quality, with influencers sometimes swayed by paid promotions. 8it, however, uses recommendations from proven food experts, not follower counts. Its practical, map-based layout focuses on action, helping you turn ideas into real meals without scrolling endlessly.

Explore More Amazing French Toast with 8it

NYC’s French toast offerings range from timeless classics to bold, creative spins, reflecting the city’s diverse food culture. Spots like Winona’s, Third Falcon, Boutros, Sarabeth’s, Sundays Well, Shopsin’s, Sarabeth’s Central Park South, and Clinton St. Baking Company each offer something distinct. Whether it’s fluffy challah with unique toppings or churro-style innovations, these eight places highlight the skill and variety in NYC’s brunch game.

Want to find more culinary treasures across the city? Skip generic searches and social media noise. Try 8it for free, the go-to app for food lovers who value expert picks over endless options.